Egads...cars like this make me want to NEVER EVER EVER buy a used car again
, especially if you choose to slyly NOT disclose the nature of the water damage, etc.
Regardless if you have fixed it or not, I feel that's something that a future owner should know...Some people are real winners though, and believe that if the potential buyer is "too stupid" not to see the repairs, then they don't deserve to know.
I worked for a used car dealer as inventory manager, and I find that NADA prices are fine tuned in the dealer's benefit. I would never use their figures to buy a car from a private party. Edmund's is indeed more realistic, and KBB is for well wishers
I would say $1900, if you truthfully disclose the history of the car. If you choose not to, may Karma be looking elsewhere next time its time for YOU to step up to the plate as the buyer, instead of the seller
